Menu change is in the air!

All that’s missing in this picture is you.

Our breakfast menu is going through some exciting changes.  Say goodbye to some favorite menu items since 2009…the Polly’s Burrito/Scramble, Veggie Burrito/Scramble, and Southwest Burrito/Scramble.  Say hello to the Polly’s “Build YOUR Own” Burrito or Scramble!  Each starts with the basics…3 delicious scramble eggs on a flour tortilla or with a side of Toast or English Muffin.  You then choose your favorite items to add…like Bacon, Veggie Sausage, Chicken, Cheese, Sour Cream, Salsa, or your favorite veggie items.  Keep it simple….or go wild.

Breakfast is served from 8 am to 11 am on weekdays and 8:30 am to 11 am on Saturday.  Stop in for breakfast soon.

Caribbean Soul Collection “6 Restaurants that we love on St Croix”

Polly’s at the Pier is proud to be included in this list of best restaurants on St Croix in a recent blog by Caribbean Soul Collection.  We could not be on this list without our amazing staff and customers.  Thanks!

Article can be viewed at this link:


Polly’s Coffee Genius at work

Why is Polly’s at the Pier’s coffee considered the best coffee on St Croix by many of our customers?  Meet Janean –  our awesome roaster.  Janean roasts every bean that goes in to our two brewed coffee options and espresso based drinks.  (No store bought coffee or corporate coffee for the Polly’s customer – only the best for you!)  Janean is a fantastic midwest roaster who is also a wonderful Bassoonist.  She ships her beans to us from her home town in Iowa to St Croix every few weeks so that Polly’s at the Pier has the freshest beans for you.

Post Maria Update- We are open!

Polly’s at the Pier survived Hurricane Maria and it’s 175mph winds with minimal damage.  Many in our community were not so fortunate….but St Croix is resilient and will is rebuilding quickly!

We have reopened the restaurant and adapting to our new way of life.  We are currently on a generator and hope to have power restored in Frederiksted in the next few weeks.  We do not have internet at this time and cannot accept credit cards.

Hours during our curfew restrictions:

8:30 – 3 pm Tuesday – Saturday.  Breakfast until 11 am and lunch from 11 – 3 pm. (we will be closed on Monday’s due to a shortage of employees as a few employees have left the island.  We hope to hire new employees in the next few months and reopen 6 days a week.)

3 – 5 pm –  open for beverages only.  Beers range from $4.50 – $6 and cocktails are $6 – $8.50.

We reopen Sunday September 17, 2017 with limited hours and menu for cruise ship

St Croix is open for business and Polly’s at the Pier will reopen a day early because of a Royal Caribbean cruise ship being rerouted to our dock on Sunday Sept 17, 2017.  We will be open from 10 am – 3 pm on Sunday.  No breakfast will be served.  Lunch will begin at 11 am with a limited menu.

Polly’s at the Pier will open on Monday, September 18 with it’s normal hours and menu!


Cruiseship menu for Sunday September 17, 2017 is:

The Gourmet Quesadilla………………………………………..$10.50

Southwest –Seasoned grilled Chicken (or substitute Tofu), Fresh house-made black bean salsa, Jalapeno, Cheddar Cheese……..served on a flour tortilla with Sour Cream & Red Salsa

Spinach – Fresh Spinach, Red Onion, Red Pepper, Feta & Mozzarella Cheese…..served on a flour tortilla with Sour Cream & Red Salsa

The Classic Cheese Quesadilla………………………………………..$9

Yummy gooey goodness of 3 fresh cheeses: Cheddar, Mozzarella, Monterey Jack….served on a flour tortilla with Sour Cream & Red Salsa

The Wraps ……………………………………….$12 (Rice Bowl option available)

Caribbean Jerk Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Pineapple, Red Pepper, Red Onion, Crisp Greens, Caribbean Jerk Lime Mayo in a Whole Wheat Tortilla

Southwest Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Fresh house-made Black Bean Salsa, Jalapeno Pepper,

Cheddar Cheese, Sour Cream, Crisp Greens in a Whole Wheat Tortilla

Greek Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Feta, Cucumber, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperoncini Peppers, Crisp Greens, Feta Cheese Dressing in a Spinach Tortilla

Veggie Wrap – Fresh house-made Hummus, Spinach, Tomato, Red Onion, Cucumber, Crisp Greens, Black Olive, Balsamic Dressing in a Whole Wheat Tortilla (vegan)

Asian Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Almonds, Chow Mein Noodles, Mandarin Oranges, Crisp Greens, Red Onion, Asian-Sesame Dressing in a Spinach Tortilla (Rice Bowl contains Gluten) (vegan)

Club Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Crisp Greens, Cheddar cheese, Crispy Bacon, Red Onion, Tomato, Ranch Dressing in a Spinach Tortilla (Rice bowl contains Gluten)

Caesar Wrap – Seasoned grilled Chicken or Tofu, Crisp Greens, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing

in a Spinach Tortilla (Not available as a Rice Bowl)

Served with your choice of Asian Slaw, Fresh Fruit, or Kettle Chips

The Garden Salads………………………………………..$11.50

Southwest Salad – Crisp Greens, House-made Black Bean Salsa, Red Onion, Red Pepper, Tomato, Gluten-free Tortilla Strips, Cheddar Cheese, Sour Cream, Red Salsa

Spinach – Fresh Spinach, Crispy Bacon, Hard Boiled Egg, Red Onion, Tomato…..served with a side of your choice of Dressing

Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Greek Feta Vinaigrette, Asian Mandarine Sesame Seed, Caesar, Blue Cheese

**Add a healthy portion of Seasoned Grilled Chicken or Tofu for $4, Polly’s Veggie Patty for $5

Post-Hurricane Irma opening

Polly’s at the Pier would like to thank everyone for the outpouring of love you have given the Polly’s family and the island of St Croix during this storm.  We are very lucky that this storm turned north and we were only left with minor damage and no electricity.  As of 10 pm, Frederiksted is back on with power except for our block on Strand.  Luckily Polly’s has been on it’s trusty generator since the storm began!

We will be opening back on Friday morning at 9 am.  We need that extra hour to put the restaurant back together.  It will be normal hours on Saturday.  Remember that we have been scheduled to be closed the week of Sept 11 – 17.  Most employees were leaving island for vacation…but this may all change due to the hurricane hitting the mainland.  We will let you know if we have to cancel vacation and will have limited opening during next week.

Hurricane Irma Closings

Here is the tentative schedule for Polly’s at the Pier for this week due to the arrival of Hurricane Irma in the area:

Tuesday –  Polly’s will be open at 8 am.  There will be no 7:30 coffee window.  We may need to close early depending on if a curfew is put in place for the afternoon.

Wednesday –  Go away Irma! Polly’s will be closed.

Thursday – Polly’s will try to open late that morning if there is no curfew and depending on possible damage.  We will be playing it by ear.

Friday –  Polly’s is hoping to be back open at 8 am (no 7:30 coffee window).  Of course this will depend on curfew and possible damage.